Cavallario's

Steak & Seafood

Steak & Seafood

Welcome to Cavs

A word for our guests...

Cavallario's Steak House is an Alexandria Bay tradition, family owned and operated since 1962. A "classic" steak house, our menu reflects items that have been our best sellers since opening. From time to time we will feature new menu items to stay on track with culinary trends.

Our menu selections are house made and we take pride in our quality, cooking, food, and service.

We appreciate your patronage. Thank You and Buon Appetito!

60+

Years Of Experience

Menu

APPETIZERS
SOUP & SALAD
FROM THE SEA
STEAKHOUSE
LAMB-DUCK-CHICKEN
ITALIAN & PASTA
SIDES
WINE
Prime Rib, Provolone & Hot Pepper Crispy Rolls $15.99

Served with Creamy Horsey Sauce

Mike's Hot Peppers$14.99

Spicy and addictive roasted marinated chilis and vegetables

Lobster Shooters$23.99

Lightly dusted fried cold water lobster tail bites, served with warm butter

Shrimp Gruyere$23.99

chunks of shrimp in garlic butter and covered in fontina & gruyere cheese (gs)

Steamed Fresh Littleneck Clams$15.99

Served with warm butter

Bacon Wrapped Scallops $16.99

Served with Creole Pepper Sauce

Shrimp Cocktail$15.99

Classic colossal shrimp with cocktail sauce

Cavatelli & Broccoli Alfredo$15.99

Cavatelli pasta and broccoli in creamy alfredo sauce

Fried Calamari$15.99

Cherry & banana peppers, drizzled with sweet Thai chili sauce

Ahi Tuna Nachos$18.99

apple, pineapple, onion, jalapeno, cilantro pico with spicy guac & Gochujang sauce

Baked French Onion Soup$8.99

Garlic Croutons and Provolone Cheese

Soup of the Day $7.99

Made Fresh, In House

Caesar$11.99

With romaine, peccorno romano and garlic croutons, house made dressing

House Salad$5.99

Grilled Chicken Caesar$19.99

Our delicious Caesar, topped with roasted sliced chicken breast

Shrimp Caesar$21.99

Our delicious Caesar, topped with our garlic prawns

Filet Mignon & Greens $28.99

Mixed greens, tomato, filet mignon medallions, onions, bleu cheese crumbles & walnuts with balsamic vinaigrette

Served with fresh baked bread & butter - add a house salad for 2.99 or 3.99 for a Caesar Salad
Alaskan King Crab Legs- 99.99

One pound jumbo sweet Alaskan King Crab served with rice

Fresh Broiled Salmon$30.99

Served with chef's rice and mustard sauce on the side

Bourbon Pecan Salmon $31.99

Topped with Bourbon glaze & toasted pecans served with chef's rice

Newport Combination$37.99

Shrimp, scallops, & crab "scampi" style served over angel hair

Shrimp Della Casa$28.99

mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, basil & olive oil served over angel hair

Lobster Tail$44.99

cold Atlantic waters, broiled with warm butter served with chef's rice

Chuck's Shore Dinner$99.00

Add a second tail for $125.00

Shrimp Cocktail - Steamed Littlenecks - House Salad

Lobster Tail - steamed, broiled, or baked with crab stuffing

with slow roasted Choice Angus Rib and mashed potato

Mahi Mahi$31.99

Cajun spiced topped with fresh mango pineapple salsa with chef's rice

Baked Stuffed Shrimp$31.99

With blue crab cornbread stuffing - warm butter and rice pilaf

Shrimp Scampi "a la Frankie"$27.99

Shrimp and garlic butter sauce served over angel hair

Shrimp, Scallops, & Crab Alfredo$38.99

served over angel hair

Stuffed Lobster Tail$47.99

Topped with our homemade crabmeat stuffing served with chef's rice

Served with fresh baked bread & butter and whipped potatoes - add a house salad for 2.99 or 3.99 for a Caesar Salad
Choice Aged Black Angus Slow Roasted Prime Rib

Queen 14oz - $39.99

King 20oz - $47.99

Choice Black Angus NY Strip$38.99

13oz; frizzled onions

Choice Black Angus Ribeye$41.99

13oz; frizzled onions

Filet Mignon$44.99

8oz - center cut broiled with asparagus and bernaise sauce

Steak Maison$39.99

twin 3oz filets with red crab, sauteed mushrooms and bernaise sauce

Cavallario's Mixed Trio$44.99

prime rib, garlic sauteed shrimp, and sea scallops

Bleu Cheese Stuffed Filet$39.99

twin 3oz filets - blackberry Cabernet glaze

Surf & Turf$62.99

twin 3oz filets and 8oz broiled lobster tail with warm butter

Prime Rib & Lobster Tail$59.99

12oz aged Angus prime rib and broiled lobster tail

Served with fresh baked bread & butter - add a house salad for 2.99 or 3.99 for a Caesar Salad
Rack of Lamb$42.99

broiled rosemary dijon butter sauce and whipped potato

Crispy Orange Duck$36.99

with grand mariner sauce and rice pilaf

Chicken Maison$29.99

topped with blue crab cornbread stuffing, rice pilaf, finished with bernaise

Chicken Francesca$27.99

egg battered breast sauteed in lemoon, butter & sherry, paired with egg fettuccine Alfredo

Chikcen Oscar$29.99

pegg battered breast, sauteed in lemon, butter & sherry, topped with lump blue crab meat, asparagus, and bernaise over rice pilaf

Chicken Della Casa$26.99

mushrooms, sun dried tomato, basil, olice oil, butter over angel hair

Chicken Parmesan$26.99

hand tenderized and breaded chicken cutlets, mozzarella & provolone with angel hair marinara

Served with fresh baked bread & butter - add a house salad for 2.99 or 3.99 for a Caesar Salad
Pasta Della Casa$21.99

mushrooms, sun dried tomato, basil, olive oil, butter over angel hair

Angel Hair & Meatballs$22.99

hand tenderized and breaded chicken cutlets, mozzarella & provolone with angel hair marinara

Chicken Riggies$26.99

a North Country favorite, grilled chicken with our hot pepper blend and rigatoni tossed in our creamy pink sauce

Baked Potato$5.00

sour cream - butter

Loaded Potato$7.00

sour cream, bacon, cheese

Loaded Mashed$7.00

sour cream, bacon, cheese

French Fries$5.00
Chef's Vegetable$5.00
Sauteed Mushrooms$4.00
Sauteed Onions$4.00
The Best Wines

Are Ones We Drink With Friends!

Come in to see our selection!
Scenic757860 - TripAdvisor (Sept 6, 2022)
Celebrating our 50th Wedding Anniversary just the 2 of us.

We wanted to make this day special (50th Anniversary) with a wonderful meal. It was a first class experience. We received a complimentary bottle of champagne and dessert from the owner. The food, prime rib and filet mignon were perfectly cooked. So glad we decided on Cavallarios and will definetely go back again.

Soups66 - Tripadvisor (Oct 5, 2022)
Still a favorite

We have come here for 40+ yrs when in Alex Bay on vacation. This latest version is wonderful. Great food, great atmosphere, and awesome staff.

Jennifer Bailey - Facebook (Aug 12, 2022)
Highly Recommend!

Highly recommend! The Prime Rib was the best we've EVER had and our servers were incredible and also the BEST we've ever had! Beautiful decor, cozy and romantic, but equally family friendly. We will absolutely be back often!! Planning on experiencing the outside dining and entertainment on the patio!